Recent discussions about tulips and mania always seem to revolve around Bitcoin. New investors have a difficult job ahead – a constant need to whip out your fully charged BS meter to determine whether or not a pro-Bitcoiner is secretly suffering from delusions of grandeur, or if an anti-Bitcoiner is quietly battling severe depression that makes everything look like crap.
Does history tells us anything?
Bitcoin is presumed to be a bubble primarily because we have not seen any other asset class move on such an enormous trajectory since the Dutch Tulips back in the 1600s, nearly 395 years ago. Contract prices for very desirable tulip bulbs topped local laborers’ annual incomes by a factor of 10, reaching outlandish levels before they tanked in February 1637.
Since the Dutch tulips were not tied to housing, food, water or the monetary system, their precipitous fall had no great fiscal impact. But Tulip mania provides an interesting lens for assessing Bitcoin in the context of social expectations. Charlie Bilello’s Twitter polls about the perception of Bitcoin and its price reveal tremendous optimism, with the majority of respondents predicting Bitcoin’s climb.
Poll Results: 65% say Bitcoin will hit 30,000 before the Dow. $BTC.X $DJIA pic.twitter.com/5FnPKDQBk2
— Charlie Bilello (@charliebilello) October 19, 2017
At the core of asset bubbles is overvaluation. What distinguishes the leading cryptocurrency from flowers is its underlying blockchain technology and the evolution of the global financial industry. If Bitcoin is the base of the revolution, it has value that is not merely intrinsic or fashionable. If it gets replaced by superior technology, it may prove to be a dinosaur as opposed to a bubble. But if it prevails and its technology keeps it as the center of our growing blockchain technology, it may go up, up, and away.
12 Asset Bubbles That Burst
1. Tulip Mania (1636-1637)
First major financial bubble; collapsed over course of one week; tulip holders went bankrupt
2. Mississippi Bubble (1716-1719)
Currency blunder and rapid sell-off of Mississippi Company stock; triggered by controlled depreciation
3. South Sea Bubble (1719-1722)
British joint-stock company dealing in government debt; insider trading on national debt consolidation
4. US Stock Market (1921-1929)
Panic selling sparked by economic decline
5. Gold (1975-1982)
Boom and bust following inflation, recession, oil crisis
6. Japanese Real Estate (1980-2003)
Uncontrolled money supply and credit expansion fueling rapid acceleration of real estate prices
7. Japanese Stock Market (1982-1992)
Sharp increase in lending prices; slowdown in real estate market
8. Dotcom Bubble (1994-2002)
Widely available venture capital; overconfidence in tech stock prices; massive increase in personal investing
9. US Housing Market (1996-2011)
Low mortgage interest rates; government mandated loans; home ownership mania
10. US Stock Market (2003-2008)
Derivatives; credit default swaps; subprime mortgage loans
11. Chinese Stock Market (2005-2008)
Inflation; rumors about government clamp down on speculative trading and raised interest rate
12. Oil (2005-2008)
Hurricane Rita threat on energy supply; speculators in oil futures; financial crisis
